Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Buffalo Chicken Fingers
Baked Stuffed Shells
Basil Pesto With Shrimp
Penne Vodka W/Chicken
About
Goodfella's Pizza Pasta & Subs
Welcome to the flavorful world of Goodfella's Pizza Pasta & Subs, located in the heart of Port St. Lucie, Florida. This vibrant eatery offers a delightful array of dishes that capture the essence of authentic Italian cuisine, all in a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. With a commitment to quality and taste, Goodfella's has become a favorite among locals craving delicious pizza, hearty pasta, and satisfying subs.
What sets Goodfella's apart is not only the generous portions but also the dedication to flavor. According to satisfied patrons, their NY-style pizza is monumental. As customer Angela Cummings vividly describes, the pizza slices are so large that they surpass her hand, leaving her tantalized and satisfied with every bite. Ricardo Rangel praises the excellent flavors and the wide variety of toppings that make the pizza truly memorable, showcasing the restaurant's emphasis on quality ingredients.
For those seeking something beyond pizza, Goodfella's menu offers a range of mouthwatering pasta dishes and cold subs. The stuffed shells and homemade lasagna, such as the savory Homemade Spinach Lasagna, bring a taste of Italian tradition to your table. Each baked dish is a testament to their culinary skill and passion, accompanied by fresh salads and signature garlic knots, ensuring a well-rounded dining experience.
A visit to Goodfella's wouldn't be complete without indulging in their delightful subs. The Italian Combo Sub and Park Ave Cold Sub are crowd favorites, packed with fresh, flavorful ingredients that satisfy every craving. Guests rave about how convenient and rewarding each meal is, with Bri Janel echoing her love for their perfectly balanced garlic knots, a true must-try alongside their scrumptious Philly cheesesteaks.
As you can see, Goodfella's Pizza Pasta & Subs is not just a place to eat; it’s a destination where flavors abound and taste reigns supreme. Whether you're dining in, ordering takeout, or enjoying delivery, the culinary experience here is consistently remarkable. With commendable service and an extensive menu, it's clear why customers like Corey Moses and Janae Jimeson keep coming back for more, falling in love with dishes like eggplant parmesan and hearty spaghetti.
If you're in the neighborhood, don't miss the chance to visit Goodfella's at 148 NW California Blvd. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Oh my land. Pizza slices bigger then my hand. And I enjoyed every bite. Even thou it took me two days to eat the different slices. ”
“ Excellent NY style pizza. The pizzas are big just like NY. The staff is great and friendly. Flavors are excellent, we love the everything on pizza, lots of meats. Prices are affordable. ”
“ Whether I am ordering takeout or delivery the food always hits the spot. I'm obsessed with the Philly, but I always get a slice if I dine in, like today. The knots are the perfect amount of oil to garlic ratio, and when I order the Greek salad, it's made with care. ”
“ Some of the best pizza in town! Looking for great food, good service, and authentic Italian taste, look no further! ”
“ Let’s just say Im addicted. Eggplant parm... chicken parm... spaghetti w/ sauce. The consistency with the product is unmatched! A1A definitely deserves 5 stars!!! ”
“ So I took my sisters out for the day and we where looking for a good pizza place and thank god we found good fellas. The best pizza ever . We are from Chicago but man this takes the cake. Thank you . Oh we had meat lovers and one hawuan amazing ”
“ My husband and I were in town for 1 night and wanted to try them out. The pizza was amazing!! So was our experience! Will definitely be back! ”
“ Quaint and comfortable atmosphere, by far one of the busiest locations, however, Jerry at the counter always makes sure that everything runs as smoothly as possible even when there's a line out the door and phones are ringing off the hook. He is honest about wait times and makes sure you're taken care of, whether you're dining in, doing take out, or delivery. ”